A Variety of Complaints

In sonnets 78,80,81, and 88 there are various complaints with or hypothetical situations of different situations of betrayal. I say "or hypothetical situations" because to me it almost seems like some of these betrayals haven't happened but that Shakespeare is brooding about the possibility of them happening.
In sonnet 78 it seems like Shakespeare is almost jealous or at least wanting more attention from the object. After explaining that the object is a gifted muse to many, Shakespeare adds, "Yet be most proud of that which I compile, whose influence is thine and born of thee." Shakespeare explains that, "In others' works thou dost but mend the style" meaning to me that Shakespeare wants this person to spend more time with him than others.
In sonnet 80 the "betrayal" is a little more personal. There is talk of one specific poet that seems to admire the object as well, and that makes Shakespeare discouraged; "O, how i faint when i of you do write, knowing a better spirit doth use your name." Shakespeare goes on to compare the object to a vast ocean with himself and this other poet as boats on the water "Your shallowest help will hold me up afloat whilst he upon your soundless deep doth ride." Then at the end Shakespeare examines the possibility that the object likes this other poet more, "Then if he thrive and i be cast away, the worst was this: my love was my decay."
Sonnet 81 is more of a hypothetical betrayal, Shakespeare is almost guilting the object into something. Shakespeare is trying to show the object he has such dedication to him that, "I shall live your epitaph to make". He goes on to tell the object that his memory will live on in his poetry forever and how he will live in the "breaths of men."
I don't really understand whats going on in sonnet 88, at first i thought Shakespeare was going through a scenario that the object kind of shunned Shakespeare, but then later on he talks of helping the object somehow and making himself feel better.??
Alex

Helping Me Understand

I must say that I didn't really get the gist of theses poems until after I read your response so thank you. I like how you described each poem seperately yet started by lumping and describing them as one general idea. However, I don't think Shakespeare was being hypothetical about these situations. From the way he wrote the sonnets he is either incredibly angry that the OOp is drifting to another or is the proverbial jealous boyfriend assuming that the OOP intends to leave him for another.
*Tina

Hypothetically Speaking

I really like how you consider a lot of these betrayal situations as hypothetical. I think we've already come across the fact that these thoughts and this love of Shake's is very private, so it makes a lot of sense that his mind has wandered to create a bunch of situations which aren't really there. That's what I tend to do. These are the thoughts of Shakespeare and not necessarily a dictation of his life.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.