In sonnet 130, Shakespeare is describing the physical appearance of the Dark Lady: dark hair and eyes, pale skin. He says that she is not a Goddess, but that his love for her is still rare. I think that this poem serves largely as just an introduction to who she is, and describing her.

Sonnet 131 is Shakespeare acknowledging that the Dark Lady is not by typical standards “beautiful”, but that her personality is worth it, “For well thou know’st to my dear doting heart/ Thou art the fairest and most precious jewel.” He says that most beautiful women know that they're beautiful and are therefore conceited and cruel. Although the Dark Lady isn't gorgeous, she is tolerable to be around.

I found sonnet 133 confusing, but after multiple readings I decided that I think that Shakespeare is referencing the OOP from his earlier sonnets, and saying that the Dark Lady is toying with both of them. He does say, "But then my friend’s heart let my poor heart bail; Whoe’er keeps me, let my heart be his guard” though, which makes me think that no matter what his relationship with the Dark Lady is, he still loves the OOP and that he is his true love.

-Hilary