Nineteen: Defining Richard
What is King Richard? I feel like he's asking himself that at this point in the play, and will be asking it more in the upcoming acts. What is he as a person, apart from being a King? He seems to have lost any identity apart from that of the crown, and all of a sudden, that's a problem. I noticed this especially as he reacted to the successive news that different people had turned against him. It seems he has few, if any friends, and merely counts on fear of God to keep people on his side. During most of act three, X seems like a man who has suddenly realized that he has massively screwed his life up, and at every turn he's discovering that it is too late to fix things. "Well, let's go find my army." "oh, sorry, they went home yesterday." *Angry rambling* "Then let's go find my uncle" "Oh, he went to the other side, too." He's discovering that he's finally run out of chances. What does X do? He responds first with hope-- but this later turns to despair. Essentially, he asses the situation, makes a lot of angry speeches, and realizes that it's over, no matter what he does. What does he mean? I'm not sure how to answer that question based on Act three. Shakespeare seems to be indicating that a King owes something to his subjects or tragedy will befall him. I also see a human connection-- if you rely on people to keep your power, you can't treat people the way King Richard seems to.
Essentially, King Richard is giving up. He's learning his lesson, but too late, and the Kingdom is going to pass into other hands.


Hah
I like how you summed up his frustration in lines 6-8. Short and sweet, but it helps to see it in such plain terms. Poor Richard. I think that this play is a tragedy simply because you have to watch someone giving up. That sucks and is generally a common fear shared by humans.
-Renee Ward
Tee Hee
I agree with Renee. Nice summary of Richard's frustration. It definitely made me laugh. Nice over all summary as well. Well thought out and all that good stuff. Although, I do think you should fix the word "assess" because right now it says "Asses"
Yes, I laughed at that too. :]
*Tina
Misspelled
Well, he pretty well assed the situation too, as far as I'm concerned, but thanks for the heads up! Yeah, his speeches were really sad, but there's such a tone of "this isn't fair and I'm three and no one's told me that things aren't fair" that I felt angry a good description.
Erin Kay Schulz
Wow!
That made me snicker. Haha. I do have to point out though... I'm not sure all of his speeches were angry. I think, as we saw today, some of them were just plain sad.
-Renee Ward
Wavering
Yeah. I think he was wavering between utter sorrow and depression for his losses and frustration that Harry, his own flesh and blood, was the one causing most of his woes.
*Tina