Journal 25- Theme?
It's difficult to say what the theme of Hamlet is from the first scene. We're being introduced to a lot of people and getting the basic situation explained to us, so there's not a whole lot of time for developing the ideas and ideals the play is trying to convey. However, I think one clear emerging idea is when one's kindred are wronged, one has a responsibility to avenge them-- basically the concept of revenge. Shakespeare has set up the perfect situation to make Hamlet mad, not only did his uncle just take over the throne and the kingdom, but he also married his mom (really fast) and is trying to act all fathery to Hamlet. (The whole scene with the King and Queen trying to make Hamlet get over his grief makes me think of a blended family and a step-dad trying to take over the father's position while the angsty teen boy ignores and spurns him.) Then, to top it off, Hamlet finds out his uncle intended for all this to happen; the king murdered his father.
The theme seems to clearly emerge as Hamlet and the Ghost talk-- the ghost immediately urges Hamlet to get revenge on Hamlet's uncle, and even when the Ghost leaves, Hamlet clearly thinks he needs to avenge the ghost.
To answer the questions what is x, etc, I'll just call the theme "revenge" although it is more specific to family and such. What is revenge? It's the idea of punishing someone who has somehow wronged you, often by doing something similar to them. The need for revenge is brought on by feelings of anger, bitterness, and perceived injustice. And the goal in getting revenge is to make yourself feel better (or honor the memory of another wronged person) through the suffering of another.
What does X do? I think the idea of someone getting revenge entertains the audience because revenge is closely tied with the notion of justice. Most people have experienced anger and felt wronged, and would love to see someone get their comeuppance, (often on a smaller scale than life and death). The audience can sympathize with Hamlet for all the wrongs he and his father have suffered and root for him as he attempts to take down the villain. The idea of a revenge plot establishes a clear good guy and bad guy for the audience to cheer for or against.
What does x mean (what will it mean as the action progresses?) I think as the action progresses, Hamlet is going to have very clear cut goals of how to avenge his father (e.g. kill his uncle and make his mom feel bad) and very clear opportunities to do that. However, I think he'll have difficulty making this happen because we've discussed how indecisive he is, so his duty to avenge his father may be neglected. Hamlet may run into opposition, people who believe that he should let go of the past and not attempt to bring justice about by his own means. It's already obvious that he can't go to his mom about this, cause she'd side with his uncle.
As a side note, I'm wondering how old Hammy's supposed to be. He's obviously old enough to know what's going on in a lot of situations, so why didn't he just inherit the throne when the King died?


Makes sense
I, as my journal entry would suggest, agree with you. I saw revenge against family as being one of the major themes emerging in the first act. I liked how you clearly answered each question. I had a little more trouble with that. But you really cleared up the "what does X mean?" question. It really helps to guide how the characters act.
Renee
Possibly...
I wondered a similar question when I read the play for the first time a few years ago, and I researched it a bit, but am not sure how reliable my source was. I learned that around the time it was set in, Denmark was run by an elective monarchy rather than a hereditary one. I think Hamlet would have been up for the throne, but it would have depended upon the voters and who they preferred. Shakespeare never seems to mention anything like that in the play, however. Though, I could be completely wrong.
Jennie
Thanks!
That's interesting... it would really help those feelings of bitterness to grow if Hamlet had tried and failed to win the throne. I kind of pictured it being an executive decision on the part of the uncle and mom. "Hammy's too young and emo. Let's get married and run the country for a while." Still, in this case Hamlet would resent that his mom didn't believe in his abilities and his uncle had jacked the crown. Basically, either way the King is screwed. He now has this young dude with a lot of raw anger and bitterness hanging around the castle. I feel like he didn't think that one through...
Erin Kay Schulz
melancholy
In Act I, when Hamlet first comes before Claudius, and Claudius is trying to persuade Hamlet to stick around, he makes mention that Hamlet is next in line for the throne. Jennie is right that Denmark was an elective monarchy, but I don't know who would do the electing since I've never looked into that. I'm going to guess, mostly because I've never heard of any functioning (and I use the term loosely) democracy between the Greeks and Americans. That could mean that the landed gentry, or something of that sort, did the electing. Bradley
Bradley