25

Sadness is the main theme of Act 1. The whole act feels so much different to the other plays we've read. Even in Merchant of Venice and Richard II, there was someone who seemed to be destined to do something good by the end of the play. In this play, the excitement of lovers with the new King and the Queen(like that of Romeo and Juliet)is overshadowed by murder and injustice. The hopes and dreams of Hamlet (like Bassanio seeking out his dream woman) are overshadowed by first wanting to leave Denmark and go to Wittenberg and then by his desire to avenge his father's death. The good friends who support Hamlet, Marcellus and Horatio, (like Antonio supports Bassanio) are overshadowed by the haunting of the ghost. Basically all of the developing themes that occur in all the other Shakespeare plays are clouded in shadows and darkness which I guess is what makes this a tragedy
For the viewers/readers of the play this sets up the worst of situations to come up. While I only know what the end of this play, it seems like the setup for Franz Kafka's Metamorphosis in which a sad depressed man has worse things happen to him and nothing gets any better. It brings out the sadness and depression in their lives.
What this means is that a) Shakespeare was probably battling some sort of extreme sadness or a time of loss at the time that he wrote this. It was beyond normal because unlike the Merchant of Venice, there isn't such a picture-perfect ending out of this setup. b) The audience will feel the pain and weight of life as Shakespeare pours out his darkest fears and dreams.

Good analysis!

I really enjoy how you tied in Metamorposis to examining Hamlet as a character. It was a great connection and the speculations you have made about Shakespeare I completely agree with, because when reading the play, one begins to identify with Hamlet and his sadness and can relate to his struggle with the "weight of life" and what is the intended purpose for an individual. I think you've done a fine job with this blog! Veronica Sparks

Depressing

So far, this play already seems so depressing. I agree that the opening themes with the Shakespeare's tragedies really foreshadow what the ending will be like. Like in the classic example of Romeo and Juliet, it stars with someone being killed in the Capulet vs Montague feud. That death shows that unless the problem is resolved, more people will die because of their differences. In Hamlet, the same thing sort of happens. It stars out with someone being killed for the throne. It seems that more death will follow for the same goal.

Good example

It's funny comparing Hamlet to Romeo and Juliet. However it brings out the truth of Shakespeare a lot better to look at the similarities between two seemingly opposite plays. Based on your thoughts of someone dying foreshadowing more death, I think of a Paulo Coelho quote. "If something happens once it will never happen again. If it happens twice, it will surely happen a third time." That is hopefully an okay paraphrase. I'm thinking way too much right now, but I love that you brought up the similarity with Romeo and Juliet.
Ryan K Bishop

wow

I didn't notice this when I first posted, but this fits with the cause/effect element that Bleck said that Aristotle said. For each of the tragedies, there is a clear cut cause for the disaster that follows in the end.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.